I would love to wear only cute shoes, like the ones below...
...but barring that (not all cute shoes have the right arches and so on), I've hit upon another way to up my shoe game: cute shoelaces. Thanks to the magic of YouTube and the wonders of modern manufacturing (when I was growing up, there were very few color choices, materials, or textures available), a person can really dress up a plain pair of sneakers. Take a look.
I suppose that these work better on a plainer shoe, but even if I never try this, I'm mesmerized just watching them. If you'd like to see more, go to YouTube and type Creative Shoe Tying (or something similar) into the search box.